另一篇是北京友谊医院做的,和ZXY说的是一篇,结果是: 1.替比夫定用药52周后降病毒能力高于拉米(6.2 log10 vs 5.4 log10) 2.拉米产生耐药性的病例是替比的两倍 3.24周时病毒载量越低,52周是用PCR检测不到病毒的可能性越大 4.24周时如果检测不到病毒,则疗效更好,变异率低,所以24周可以预测一年的疗效 [The degree of HBV suppression with 24 week telbivudine- or lamivudine-treatment in hepatitis B patients predicts the efficacy of the treatment at week 52][Article in Chinese]
Jia JD, Hou JL, Yin YK, Xu DZ, Tan DM, Niu JQ, Zhou XQ, Wang YM, Zhu LM, He YW, Ren H, Wan MB, Chen CW, Wu SM, Chen YG, Xu JZ, Wang QH, Wei L, Ma H. Liver Research Center, Beijing Friendship Hospital, Capital Medical University, Beijing 100050, China. [email protected] OBJECTIVES: To investigate the possibilities of an association between the degrees of HBV suppression with nucleoside treatments at week 24 and week 52 in hepatitis B patients and to find a useful predictor for treatment efficacy. METHODS: In this phase III, double-blind, multicenter trial, we compared the efficacy of telbivudine treatment with lamivudine treatment in 332 Chinese compensated chronic hepatitis B patients. The patients were randomly assigned to a daily 600 mg telbivudine treatment group or daily 100 mg lamivudine group for 24 weeks. They were then categorized into 4 groups according to their serum HBV DNA levels (copies/ml) at week 24: a PCR-undetectable group (< 300 copies/ml); a QL- < 10(3) copies/ml group; a 10(3)-<10(4) copies/ml group; and a > or = 10(4) copies/ml group. The treatments were continued as they previously had been for another 28 weeks and the patients serum HBV DNA levels were examined again. RESULTS: At week 52, mean reductions of serum HBV DNA were significantly greater in the telbivudine-treated patients than in the lamivudine-treated group (6.2 log10 vs 5.4 log10, t = 3.6, P < 0.01). Viral resistance was twice as common in lamivudine-treated patients compared to those receiving telbivudine. Telbivudine was well-tolerated with an adverse event profile similar to that of lamivudine. The lower the HBV DNA level achieved at week 24, the higher HBV DNA non-detectable by PCR. ALT normalization and HBeAg seroconversion achieved at week 52, and viral resistance at week 48 decreased parallel to the degree of HBV DNA inhibition. CONCLUSION: HBV DNA PCR-undetectable at week 24 in nucleoside-treated hepatitis B patients suggests a better efficacy at week 52 and lower viral resistance at week 48. The degree of suppression of HBV at week 24 may be used as a predictor of 1-year outcome.
[此贴子已经被作者于2007-9-8 11:11:45编辑过]
|